Introduction
To the public, a court letting a criminal go free often looks like the system is slow or the defense lawyers are playing tricks. However, for those of us who cross-examine witnesses and fight cases in , the truth is simple: the government often hands us the keys to winning the case on day one.
In law, the prosecution must prove a person is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. When you look for the best criminal lawyer in Malakand or the best criminal advocate in Swat, you want someone who knows that a case is won long before final arguments. Cases are often lost not because the suspect is innocent, but because the people investigating the crime do not know how to collect evidence properly.
1. The Levies Problem: Old Ways in Modern Times
While most of the province uses the regular police, District Malakand still relies heavily on the Malakand Levies. The Levies were created a long time ago as a tribal force, and they do not have the training required to solve modern crimes.
┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ THE INVESTIGATION GAP │
├────────────────────────────┬─────────────────────────────┤
│ Trained Police Force │ Malakand Levies │
├────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────┤
│ Trained in police colleges │ Traditional tribal guards │
│ Know the law and rules │ Little to no legal training │
│ Have separate detective │ No special training for │
│ teams │ solving complex crimes │
└────────────────────────────┴─────────────────────────────┘
Not Knowing the Basics of Criminal Cases
When a defense lawyer looks at a case file made by the Levies, we usually find many big mistakes. Many officers do not understand the basic rules of criminal law:
- 📍 Wrongly Drawn Maps of the Crime Scene: An officer usually draws a rough map of the crime scene without taking exact measurements. During a murder trial, a defense lawyer can easily prove that the eyewitnesses could not have actually seen the crime from where they were standing.
- 📦 Mishandling Evidence: Evidence must be sealed and kept safe so no one can tamper with it. The Levies often do not know these rules. Weapons and drugs are frequently mishandled. When this happens, the judge cannot accept the evidence in court.
- 📡 Not Using Modern Technology: In today’s world, cases are solved using cell phone data and DNA. The Levies do not have the training to use these tools, so they rely entirely on people telling stories.
2. My Perspective: From the Chambers of Adv. Irfan Muazam
As a practicing trial lawyer, I see these weak files every single day in the courtroom. We cannot claim we have a fixed justice system when the people investigating crimes have not been trained to do so.
From my perspective at ADV IRFAN MUAZAM Law Associates, I often meet Levies investigators who come to court completely unprepared. They do not know the basic steps of a criminal case. I think they operate more like traditional tribal elders than trained detectives.
When a serious crime happens, people looking for the best criminal lawyer in Malakand want someone who will fight hard for them [queryLocation://<Malakand, Pakistan>/]. The victims and the accused both deserve a real investigation. Instead, we are given fake-looking, copied-and-pasted reports that any competent best criminal advocate in Swat can easily tear apart in a few minutes [queryLocation://<Swat, Pakistan>/]. I will always fight for my clients’ rights, but it is sad to see the justice system lose respect because the government refuses to update how it investigates crimes.
3. How the Defense Wins: Mistakes the State Makes
[Crime Happens] ──► [Delayed Report] ──► [Ruined Crime Scene] ──► [Flawed Statements] ──► [Case Dismissed]
Relying Only on Eyewitnesses (The Trap)
Because the Levies and local police often cannot gather physical proof, they rely mostly on people saying they saw the crime. This is the weakest part of their case.
- Why Witnesses Fail: People who see a crime can easily be pressured, change their stories, or simply forget what happened over the years while the trial drags on.
- The Reality in Court: The moment a witness changes their story or contradicts themselves, the state’s case falls apart. If there is no physical evidence, the judge has to let the accused go.
Copy-Paste Reports
Police often use the same recycled text for filing cases. In drug or weapon cases, the reports look exactly the same even when the cases are totally different. A good defense lawyer spots this easily and proves to the judge that the police report was simply made up.
4. Other Legal Roadblocks
The Rule on Police Statements
Under the law, any statements recorded by the police cannot be used as final, solid proof in court. When the witness comes to court to testify, the defense lawyer compares their live story to what they told the police earlier. If there are big differences, the witness loses all credibility.
Confessions Made to the Police
A lot of times, the police say a suspect confessed while in their custody. However, under the law, no confession made directly to a police officer can be used in court to prove someone is guilty. Because the police rely on these forced confessions instead of looking for real proof, their cases fall apart as soon as the suspect takes back the confession in front of a judge.
5. Why People Lose Faith in the Courts
When the government cannot successfully prosecute criminals, the public loses trust. When people see that the official courts cannot solve land disputes or murders, they take matters into their own hands. They go to local tribal councils to settle things, which weakens the formal law and replaces constitutional rights with old customs.
How to Fix the System
To truly fix the justice system in Malakand, the government needs to make real changes:
- Remove Levies’ Investigation Powers: Take investigation duties away from the Levies and give them to trained police officers, or give the Levies proper legal training.
- Involve Prosecutors Early On: A prosecutor should review the case with the police within 48 hours so that big mistakes can be fixed immediately.
- Set Up Local Crime Labs: Bring modern forensic tools to the local area so evidence does not get ruined while being sent to other cities.
- Separate Duties: Separate the police who investigate crimes from the police who just do everyday patrols and security.
From the Desk of Counsel
As defense lawyers, we use these investigation mistakes to protect our clients’ freedom. However, as citizens, we must realize that a broken justice system hurts the entire society. Real justice should come from strong proof, not just because the police did not know the law.
What are your thoughts on this issue?
- Have you ever dealt with a case where a bad police investigation ruined a case?
- Is it time to finally remove the Levies’ power to investigate crimes?
Leave your insights in the comments section below to join the professional discussion.
🏛️ Need Expert Legal Counsel or Representation?
If you are facing legal challenges, criminal accusations, trial proceedings, or tax issues, securing the right legal partner is important. Contact our chambers to consult with the best criminal lawyer in Malakand and the best criminal advocate in Swat:
- 🌐 Official Website: advirfanmuazam.com
- 📍 Chambers Address: Floor No. 1, Adv Irfan Muazam, Near Swat Shopping Mall, Opposite to Darul Qaza Mingora, Swat, KPK
- 📞 Direct Contact / WhatsApp Support: +92 346 2066302
- ✉️ Email: info@advirfanmuazam.com